Why We Need More Older Women at the Center of Stories

There is a particular way fiction tends to treat old women. They appear at the edges, useful, then departing. They are the grandmothers who say something wise before the funeral scene. They are the neighbors who reveal the protagonist’s backstory. They are the patients whose decline teaches the younger characters something about mortality. And then they are gone, having served their purpose in someone else’s story.
🌍 OBSERVANCE NOTE
International Day of Older Persons • October 1
Observed annually on October 1, the United Nations International Day of Older Persons marked its 35th year in 2025 under the theme “Older Persons Driving Local and Global Action: Our Aspirations, Our Well-Being, Our Rights.” The UN’s Secretary-General António Guterres noted that older persons are “powerful agents of change” whose voices must shape policy, end age discrimination, and build inclusive societies. This week’s Tuesday feature begins there, and asks what fiction is doing about it.
There is a particular way fiction tends to treat old women. They appear at the edges — useful, then departing. They are the grandmothers who say something wise before the funeral scene. They are the neighbors who reveal the protagonist’s backstory. They are the patients whose decline teaches the younger characters something about mortality. And then they are gone, having served their purpose in someone else’s story.
This week we are thinking about what it would look like to give older women the center. Not as symbols. Not as plot mechanisms. Not as cautionary tales or consolation prizes. As full people — with history, desire, contradiction, and the right to be as complex at eighty-eight as they were at twenty-five.
Lois Lowry does exactly this in Tree. Table. Book., a novel that is officially for children and actually for everyone. And Sarai Johnson does it again, from a completely different angle, in Grown Women, which comes to us on Thursday. Together they form something rare: a week in which older women are not supporting characters in someone else’s story. They are the story.
✦ TUESDAY FEATURE • OCTOBER 13 Tree. Table. Book. by Lois Lowry Clarion Books • April 23, 2024 • 208 pages • Ages 9 and up (and all adults) Two-time Newbery Medalist (The Giver, Number the Stars) Everyone in town knows the two Sophies are best friends. Sophie Winslow is eleven years old. Sophie Gershowitz is eighty-eight. They drink tea, disagree about nearly everything, and love each other unreservedly, which is why Sophie Winslow is beside herself when old Sophie’s son decides his mother’s memory lapses are signs of dementia and begins making arrangements to move her to assisted living. What Sophie Winslow sets out to prove is that her friend is not diminished, she is deep. Behind the word-finding struggles and the moments of confusion is a woman who survived the Holocaust under multiple names, carried a language and a history across an ocean, and has been quietly depositing wisdom into the life of a lonely eleven-year-old for years. The title comes from the three-word memory test Sophie Gershowitz is asked to repeat during a cognitive assessment, a clinical test that cannot begin to measure what she actually holds inside her. This is a middle-grade novel, nominally. But like all of Lois Lowry’s best work, it refuses to be contained by its intended audience. Adults who have watched an elderly person’s world narrow, who have sat across from someone trying to hold onto words that keep slipping, will find this book addresses them just as directly as it addresses any child. Why this book, this week: Tree. Table. Book. gives its oldest character the richest interior life in the story. Sophie Gershowitz is not a burden, a cautionary tale, or a symbol of what is lost. She is a full person, with history, humor, opinions, and a relationship worth fighting for. That is exactly what the International Day of Older Persons is asking fiction to do. |
The Problem with How Fiction Treats Older Women
The Problem, in Plain Terms
Research on age representation in fiction consistently finds the same pattern: older women appear far less frequently than their proportion of the population, and when they do appear, they are most commonly cast as mothers or grandmothers defined by their relationship to younger characters, not as protagonists with autonomous desires, curiosity, or stories of their own.
What fiction routinely offers older women:
→ The wise grandmother who imparts a lesson and then exits.
→ The frail elder whose decline drives the plot of a younger character.
→ The comic eccentric who says outrageous things because she’s past caring.
→ The safely-dead matriarch whose absence explains why everyone is the way they are.
What this week’s books offer instead:
✔ Sophie Gershowitz (Tree. Table. Book.): an elder who is the emotional and moral center of her own story.
✔ Evelyn (Grown Women): a matriarch who is complex, accountable, and given the full weight of her contradictions.
Both novels argue, in their different registers, that an older woman’s interior life does not become less interesting with age. It becomes more so, denser with history, more precise in its understanding of consequence, and more quietly radical in its insistence on being fully itself.
The Gallery: Older Women Who Own Their Stories
These are the characters who got it right — older women given the full weight of an interior life, a history, and a plot that belongs to them:
Sophie Gershowitz Tree. Table. Book. — Lois Lowry THE KEEPER A Holocaust survivor who crossed an ocean, changed her name twice, and arrived in a New Hampshire suburb still carrying history no three-word test can measure. Her friendship with an eleven-year-old is not consolation, it is chosen, mutual, and entirely on her own terms. | Olive Kitteridge Olive Kitteridge — Elizabeth Strout THE DIFFICULT ONE Olive is abrasive, blunt, often wrong about the people she loves, and one of the most fully realized characters in American fiction. Strout refuses to soften her or explain her. She simply lets Olive be herself, difficult and indispensable, across a lifetime of small Maine moments. |
COMING THURSDAY • PREVIEW Evelyn — Grown Women by Sarai Johnson THE MATRIARCH Evelyn is the oldest generation at the center of Johnson’s four-generation saga of Black women, erudite, exacting, and the source of both the family’s greatest strengths and its deepest wounds. She is exactly the kind of older woman fiction too rarely gives us: complicated, fully responsible for her choices, neither sentimentalized nor dismissed. Full feature Thursday. | |
What Great Portrayal Actually Requires
Positive representation of older women in fiction is not about making them likable or peaceful or past conflict. It is about giving them the same novelistic treatment any protagonist deserves. Here is what that looks like in practice:
What it requires | What this means on the page | The book that does it best |
A history | The character’s age is not incidental. She has lived through things that changed her, and those things are present in how she thinks, speaks, and sees. | Tree. Table. Book. Sophie Gershowitz survived the Holocaust under three different names. Her history is not backstory. It is who she is. |
A present tense | She is not only defined by what she has lost or done. She has opinions, desires, and relationships that are alive right now, in the novel’s time. | Olive Kitteridge whose wants and irritations and affections are entirely present-tense, even when the novel looks back. |
Accountability | She can be wrong, can cause harm, can have failed the people she loves — and the novel does not excuse her or explain it away. | Grown Women (Thursday) Evelyn is the source of real damage in her family, and Johnson holds her fully responsible without reducing her. |
Interior life | We spend time inside her actual thoughts not just her role in the plot, but the texture of how she experiences the world. | Granny Weatherwax (Discworld) Pratchett spends enormous care on what it feels like to be Esme Weatherwax inside her own head. |
The right to end | Her arc is allowed to close on her own terms not on the terms of a younger character’s emotional journey. | Mabel in The Snow Child whose story resolves in a way that honors her grief and her reconstitution, not just her function in the plot. |
What the Title Tells Us
Tree. Table. Book. These are the three words Sophie Gershowitz is asked to remember and repeat as part of a cognitive screening test. It is a clinical protocol — bland, efficient, and designed to sort the cognitively intact from the potentially impaired.
By making these words her title, Lois Lowry does something quietly devastating. She takes the reductive instrument by which an institution proposes to measure an eighty-eight-year-old woman and holds it up against everything else that woman is: a Holocaust survivor, a Polish immigrant, a keeper of three languages, a friend to a lonely child, a person of fierce humor and specific opinions and enormous underground love.
The test cannot see any of that. The test can only tell you whether she held onto three words. And Sophie Winslow’s entire project in the novel — and, by extension, the novel’s entire argument — is that the test is asking the wrong question. The question is not whether Sophie Gershowitz can pass an assessment. The question is whether the people around her are paying enough attention to know who they are dealing with.
That question — are we paying enough attention? — is also the question the International Day of Older Persons is asking. And it is the question both of this week’s books answer with a resounding, complicated yes.
COMING THURSDAY • BOOK OF THE WEEK Grown Women by Sarai Johnson HarperCollins • 2024 • NAACP Image Award Winner • Zora Award for Debut Fiction • New Yorker Best Book of the Year Erudite Evelyn. Her cynical daughter Charlotte. Charlotte’s optimistic daughter Corinna. And Corinna’s young daughter, just beginning to understand what it means to be born into this particular lineage of women. Sarai Johnson’s debut novel covers fifty years of relationships between four generations of Black women, their love for each other, their damage to each other, and the slow, uneven work of figuring out what forgiveness actually looks like when it isn’t easy. Where it fits this week: If Tree. Table. Book. asks what we lose when we reduce an older woman to her diagnosis, Grown Women asks what we lose when we reduce a matriarch to her function. Evelyn is not a simple origin story for Charlotte’s damage. She is a full person who made full choices, and Johnson’s most radical act is holding all four of these women, at every age, to exactly that standard. Thursday’s feature will include a full review, a conversation about multigenerational storytelling and what each generation can and cannot see about the others, and reading group questions for both books paired together. |
Happy reading this Tuesday.
May the older women in your life — on the page and off it — be seen for exactly what they hold.
The Reading Room • Tuesday, October 13 • Next issue: Thursday, October 16 — Grown Women by Sarai Johnson


Comments